May 05, 2017· Eyebrow Lift Cream. The Claims: Applying anti-aging creams to the eye area and above the eyebrow can lift, tighten and firm the skin. Proponents of this method tout it as a quick, painless, inexpensive way to achieve a brow lift. They also claim that this inhibits the contraction of muscle cells, lifting the eyebrow. Verdict: Minimally effective.